Phantom Big Cats

How to tell if bobcat or mountain lion?

How to tell a bobcat from a mountain lion: tail length, size, coat, ears and tracks, plus tips for judging trail camera photos and avoiding common mix-ups.

On this page
  1. The quick answer: look at the tail
  2. Side-by-side comparison
  3. The key differences in detail
  4. Two common traps: spotted kittens and odd-colored bobcats
  5. Identifying a cat on a trail camera or doorbell camera
  6. Where each cat lives
  7. Behavior and signs they leave
  8. What to do if you think it was a mountain lion

The quick answer: look at the tail

The single best way to tell a bobcat from a mountain lion is the tail. A bobcat has a short, stubby tail, usually only about 4 to 7 inches long, that looks cut off. A mountain lion has a long, thick, rope-like tail, roughly 2 to 3 feet long, often with a dark tip, that hangs down and curves up near the end.

If you can see the tail clearly, you can usually settle it in a second. If you can’t, check size, coat pattern and ears:

  • Bobcat: about twice the size of a large house cat, spotted or streaked coat, pointed ears with black tufts
  • Mountain lion: much bigger and longer, plain tawny coat with no spots on adults, rounded ears without tufts

Side-by-side comparison

Feature Bobcat Mountain lion (cougar, puma)
Tail Short, “bobbed,” about 4–7 in; black on top of the tip, white underneath Long, thick, about 25–35 in; dark tip
Weight (adult) Roughly 15–35 lb, occasionally more Roughly 60–100 lb for females, 100–160+ lb for males
Length (nose to tail tip) About 2.5–3.5 ft About 6–8 ft
Height at shoulder About 1.5–2 ft About 2–2.5 ft
Coat Tan, reddish or gray with dark spots and bars Plain tawny, tan or grayish-brown; adults unspotted
Ears Pointed, black tufts, white spot on the back Rounded, no tufts, dark on the back
Face Ruff of fur on the cheeks, “sideburns” Smoother face, dark marks at the sides of the muzzle
Legs Long legs relative to body, bobbed rear Long, low, muscular body
Front track width About 2 in About 3–4.5 in

All measurements are approximate and vary by region, sex and age.

The key differences in detail

Tail

The tail is the most reliable feature because it doesn’t depend on judging distance. Even a young mountain lion has a tail that is long relative to its body. A bobcat’s tail never is. Look for the bobcat’s distinctive tail tip: black on top, white underneath, which can flash as the cat moves away.

Size and build

A bobcat is a mid-sized cat, often compared to a medium dog or a very large house cat. A grown mountain lion is closer in size to a large dog or a small adult person on all fours, with a long, low body.

Size is harder to judge than people think, especially at a distance, at dusk or in a photo. Use it as supporting evidence rather than the main clue.

Coat and markings

Bobcats are spotted. The spots can be bold or faint, and the background color ranges from reddish-tan to gray, but there are usually visible spots or bars on the legs and belly. Adult mountain lions have a plain, uniform coat, typically tan to grayish-brown, with a paler belly and throat.

Ears and face

Bobcats have pointed ears tipped with short black tufts and a white spot on the back of each ear. Their faces look wide because of the fur ruff on the cheeks. Mountain lion ears are rounded and lack tufts. Their heads look small relative to their large bodies.

Tracks

Both species leave classic cat tracks: no claw marks in most cases, four toes with one leading, and a heel pad with three lobes at the back. The main difference is size. Adult bobcat prints are around 2 inches wide; adult mountain lion prints are around 3 inches or more. For the full breakdown, see our guide to identifying mountain lion tracks.

Two common traps: spotted kittens and odd-colored bobcats

Spotted mountain lion kittens. Mountain lion kittens are born with dark spots and ringed tails. The spots fade gradually and are usually gone or very faint by the time the young cats are around a year old or a little older. A spotted, long-tailed cat seen with a large tawny adult is almost certainly a family of mountain lions, not bobcats. And if there are kittens, the mother is nearby, so keep your distance.

Unusual bobcats. Bobcats vary a lot in color, and very rarely individuals with very dark coats have been documented, particularly in Florida. Unusually large, plain-looking bobcats, or a bobcat seen side-on in long grass with its tail hidden, can be mistaken for a mountain lion. Dark cats are also a frequent source of black panther sightings in the US.

Identifying a cat on a trail camera or doorbell camera

Camera footage is now the most common way people encounter either cat, and also the most common source of mistakes. Wide-angle lenses distort size, and infrared night images remove color, so spots and tawny coats can look the same.

To identify a cat in footage:

  1. Pause on the clearest frame showing the tail. That alone often settles it.
  2. Measure something it walked past. Go out with a tape measure and measure a fence rail, step, flower pot or gate the cat passed. Compare the cat’s height or length to that object in the frame. This is the best way to judge size.
  3. Look at multiple frames. Spots on a bobcat often show in at least one frame even on infrared.
  4. Check the ears if the cat faces the camera.
  5. Compare with a known animal. If your own dog or cat walks past the same spot, use that footage as a scale reference.

Where each cat lives

Bobcats are widespread across most of the continental United States, southern Canada and northern Mexico, in forests, deserts, swamps, farmland and suburbs. They’re common in many places where people rarely realize they are present.

Mountain lions have a narrower range in the US today: mainly the western states and western Canada, with a small, protected population of Florida panthers in southern Florida. Small numbers also occur in parts of the Great Plains and Midwest, and young males occasionally wander much farther east.

If you live in the eastern US outside Florida, the odds strongly favor a bobcat, a house cat or a dog over a mountain lion. In the West, either is possible. Even in mountain lion country, sightings are uncommon; see how rare it is to see a mountain lion.

Behavior and signs they leave

  • Prey: Mountain lions mainly hunt deer and other large prey. Bobcats mostly take rabbits, rodents and birds, and occasionally small deer.
  • Kills: Mountain lions often drag a large kill to a hidden spot and cover it with leaves, soil or snow to return to later. Bobcats may cover kills too, but they are much smaller.
  • Activity: Both are most active around dawn, dusk and night. Bobcats are seen in daylight fairly often, especially in suburbs.
  • Sounds: Both can scream, yowl and hiss, so sounds alone are a poor way to tell them apart.

What to do if you think it was a mountain lion

  • Keep children and pets close, and bring pets in at night.
  • Don’t approach the animal or any carcass you find.
  • Save your photos or footage, and measure reference objects near where it was seen.
  • If it was near homes, behaving boldly, or in an area where mountain lions aren’t known to live, report it to your state wildlife agency.

Most “mountain lion” reports in the eastern US turn out to be bobcats or other animals, which is one reason phantom big cats remain such a persistent mystery. A clear tail shot and a measured reference object are the two things that make a report genuinely useful.

The complete guide to phantom big cats

Phantom Big Cats: Sightings, Evidence and Explanations
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →