North American Folklore

What's the scariest Native American folklore?

The Wendigo, skinwalkers, Spearfinger, Flying Heads and more: the most frightening Native American folklore, and the lessons these stories were told to teach.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Wendigo (Algonquian peoples)
  3. Skinwalkers (Navajo)
  4. Spearfinger (Cherokee)
  5. Raven Mockers (Cherokee)
  6. Flying Heads (Haudenosaunee)
  7. Rolling Heads (Plains and other nations)
  8. Baykok (Ojibwe)
  9. Stikini (Seminole)
  10. Skadegamutc, the ghost witch (Wabanaki)
  11. Teihiihan (Cheyenne)
  12. What these stories were for
  13. A note on respect

The short answer

The Wendigo of the Algonquian-speaking peoples is the most common answer. It’s a starving, ice-hearted, cannibal being of the northern winter whose hunger only grows the more it eats. Close behind are the Navajo skinwalker, a human witch who takes animal form to do harm, and the Cherokee Spearfinger, a stone-skinned witch who disguised herself as a kindly old woman to steal children’s livers.

“Scariest” depends on who’s listening. And there’s no single “Native American folklore,” only the distinct traditions of hundreds of nations. Below are ten of the most frightening beings, each with the nation it comes from and what its story was meant to teach.

Wendigo (Algonquian peoples)

Nations: Ojibwe, Cree, Innu and other Algonquian-speaking peoples of the northern forests and the Great Lakes.

The Wendigo (also windigo, wiindigoo, witiko) is tied to winter, starvation and cannibalism. In many accounts a person becomes a Wendigo by eating human flesh in desperation, or by being possessed by the Wendigo spirit. Traditional descriptions stress a gaunt, emaciated, human-like figure, sometimes with a heart of ice, sometimes gigantic, always hungry. It grows as it eats, so it can never be full.

The lesson: greed and selfishness destroy communities. In hard times you share, and you never cross the line into consuming others.

The antlered, deer-skulled Wendigo of modern films and games is mostly a recent pop-culture invention and doesn’t reflect most traditional descriptions.

Skinwalkers (Navajo)

Nation: Navajo (Diné).

A skinwalker, yee naaldlooshii (“by means of it, it goes on all fours”), is a human witch who uses evil power to take animal form, often a coyote, wolf, owl or other creature. Skinwalkers are the opposite of healers and are associated with harm, death and broken taboos. Many Navajo people are reluctant to talk about them at all.

The lesson: spiritual power can be twisted toward harm, and some lines must never be crossed.

Our article on skinwalkers in Navajo belief explains the tradition and how it differs from internet horror stories.

Spearfinger (Cherokee)

Nation: Cherokee.

Spearfinger (U’tlun’ta) is a witch with skin as hard as stone and a long, blade-like forefinger. She wandered the mountains disguised as an old woman or a trusted relative, coaxing children close so she could stab them and take their livers. Her victims often didn’t know they had been wounded until they sickened and died. She was finally killed when a small bird revealed that her heart was hidden in her closed hand.

The lesson: be wary of strangers, and of people who seem kind but act strangely.

Raven Mockers (Cherokee)

Nation: Cherokee.

Raven Mockers are witches who fly through the night in a fiery form, crying like a diving raven. They gather invisibly around the sick and dying, torment them, and steal their hearts, adding the victims’ remaining years to their own lives. Only a medicine person can see them or drive them off.

The lesson: the sick are vulnerable and must be watched over, and there are people who prey on weakness.

More on both Cherokee figures appears in our guides to Cherokee monsters and Cherokee shapeshifters.

Flying Heads (Haudenosaunee)

Nations: Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) peoples.

The Flying Heads (often given as Kanontsistóntie’s and similar spellings) are huge disembodied heads with streaming hair and great jaws. They fly through storms and devour whatever they find. In one well-known story, a woman roasting chestnuts by her fire appears to be eating hot coals. A watching Flying Head is so terrified by her apparent power that it flees.

The lesson: courage and quick wits can defeat even overwhelming terror.

Rolling Heads (Plains and other nations)

Nations: versions appear among the Cheyenne, Cree, Ojibwe and others.

In Rolling Head stories, a severed head, often born from a terrible act of betrayal or violence within a family, refuses to die. It bounces or rolls after its relatives, crushing or devouring everything in its path until it is stopped, often by crossing water or by a helper’s power.

The lesson: violence within the family has consequences that pursue you.

Baykok (Ojibwe)

Nation: Ojibwe (Anishinaabe).

The Baykok, also spelled bakaak and in other ways, is a skeletal being associated with hunters who died in the woods. In popular retellings it stalks hunters, shoots them with invisible arrows or strikes them with a club, and eats their livers. Traditional sources vary, and some of the grisliest modern details may be later additions.

The lesson: the dead deserve proper respect, and the woods carry real danger.

Stikini (Seminole)

Nations: Seminole and Miccosukee.

Stikini are witches who look like ordinary people by day. At night they vomit up their souls and organs, take the form of owls, and hunt for human hearts. In some communities just saying their name is thought to be dangerous, so their stories are told carefully.

The lesson: evil can hide inside the community, behind familiar faces.

Skadegamutc, the ghost witch (Wabanaki)

Nations: Wabanaki peoples of Maine and the Maritimes, including the Mi’kmaq, Maliseet and Passamaquoddy.

The Skadegamutc (spellings vary, including Skudakumooch) is an undead witch, a sorcerer who returns after death to kill and eat the living at night. It can be destroyed only by fire. In one often-told account, a woman camping near a burial ground hears gnawing in the dark and wakes to find her husband’s body half eaten.

The lesson: dark power doesn’t die with the person who wielded it, and places of the dead deserve caution.

Teihiihan (Cheyenne)

Nation: Cheyenne.

The Teihiihan are small, child-sized beings who are far stronger than they look. In Cheyenne stories they were fierce cannibals who attacked in numbers until several nations allied to drive them out. Other nations have very different little people, some playful, some protective. The Wampanoag pukwudgies fall somewhere in between.

The lesson: never judge strength by size.

What these stories were for

Many of these beings work as warnings. Don’t hoard food in winter. Don’t go alone into the woods. Watch over the sick. Don’t trust every kind face. Respect the dead. The fear is the point, because a story that frightens you is a story you remember. Some of them also mark the edges of acceptable behaviour, showing what a person becomes when they put their own hunger above everyone else.

A note on respect

Several of these beings, particularly witches like skinwalkers, Raven Mockers and Stikini, are tied to beliefs some people still hold seriously. Some nations have rules about who may tell these stories, when, and to whom. If you’re interested, look for versions told by members of the nation the story belongs to, and treat horror movies and viral videos as entertainment.

For a wider look at the continent’s legendary beings, including non-Indigenous ones, see our guide to North American folklore creatures.

The complete guide to north american folklore

North American Folklore Creatures
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →