Loch Ness Monster

The Loch Ness eDNA Survey: What the DNA Found and the Giant Eel Theory

What the 2018 Loch Ness environmental DNA survey found: no reptile DNA, lots of eel DNA, and why the giant eel theory survives but faces real problems.

On this page
  1. What is environmental DNA?
  2. How the Loch Ness survey worked
  3. What the DNA found
  4. How the Nessie theories fared
  5. The giant eel theory
  6. The limits of the survey
  7. What the survey means for Nessie

In 2018 a team of scientists tried something new at Loch Ness. Instead of looking for the monster, they tested the water for traces of DNA from everything living in it. The results, announced in September 2019, found no sign of a reptile, a shark, a catfish or a sturgeon. They did find a surprising amount of eel DNA, which gave the long-standing giant eel theory a fresh lease of life.

What is environmental DNA?

Every living thing sheds DNA into its surroundings, through skin cells, scales, mucus, waste and so on. In water this material, known as environmental DNA or eDNA, drifts around for a while before breaking down. By filtering water samples and sequencing the DNA they contain, scientists can build up a list of species present in a lake or river without needing to see, catch or photograph them.

eDNA surveys are widely used in conservation, for example to track invasive species or detect rare fish. Loch Ness, with its dark, peat-stained water and long history of inconclusive sightings, was an obvious place to try it.

How the Loch Ness survey worked

The project was led by Neil Gemmell, a geneticist at the University of Otago in New Zealand, with collaborators in several countries. In June 2018 the team collected around 250 water samples from different locations and depths around the loch.

The DNA from those samples was sequenced, producing a very large number of DNA sequences (reported at around 500 million). These were compared against reference databases to work out which organisms they came from. Gemmell presented the findings at a press event near the loch in September 2019.

What the DNA found

The survey identified roughly 3,000 species, the large majority of them bacteria and other microscopic life. Among larger animals, it found DNA from the loch’s known fish and from land animals living around it, such as deer, along with traces from people and livestock.

The headline results for the monster question were:

  • No reptile DNA. Nothing related to plesiosaurs or any other reptile was detected.
  • No large exotic fish. No DNA from sturgeon, Wels catfish or Greenland sharks, all of which have been suggested as Nessie candidates.
  • Lots of eel DNA. European eel DNA turned up at almost every sampling site, in quantities the team described as surprising.

How the Nessie theories fared

Theory What the eDNA showed
Surviving plesiosaur or other reptile No reptile DNA detected
Giant sturgeon No sturgeon DNA detected
Wels catfish No catfish DNA detected
Greenland shark No shark DNA detected
Giant eel Eel DNA abundant, but DNA can’t reveal size
Ordinary animals (otters, deer, birds) Many known local species detected

The survey was not designed to “prove” or “disprove” Nessie on its own, but it was a serious blow to the reptile explanation. For the other arguments against a plesiosaur, including the loch’s young age and the problem of air-breathing animals going unseen, see our complete guide to the Loch Ness Monster.

The giant eel theory

The idea that Nessie might be an unusually large eel is not new. It has been suggested for decades, partly because eels are well known in the loch and partly because some witnesses describe a long, sinuous body. The eDNA survey didn’t prove the theory, but Gemmell said it meant giant eels could not be ruled out as an explanation for at least some sightings.

How big do European eels get?

The European eel (Anguilla anguilla) has a remarkable life cycle. It is thought to spawn in the Sargasso Sea in the western Atlantic. The larvae drift towards Europe, enter rivers as young “glass eels” and spend years, sometimes decades, growing in fresh water before returning to the ocean to breed.

Most adult European eels are well under a metre long; large females can approach or slightly exceed a metre, and exceptional specimens are reported to be somewhat larger. That is a big fish, but nowhere near the several-metre animals many Nessie witnesses describe. The species is also considered critically endangered, after steep declines in recent decades.

Problems with a giant eel

The giant eel idea runs into several difficulties:

  • No evidence of giants. There is no confirmed record of eels in Loch Ness, or anywhere in Europe, approaching the size of a typical Nessie report. eDNA tells you a species is present, not how big individual animals are.
  • The wrong posture. Eels swim by side-to-side undulation and don’t normally lift their heads and necks out of the water. That doesn’t fit the classic long-necked image, although that image owes a great deal to the faked surgeon’s photograph.
  • The wrong habits. Eels spend much of their time near the bottom and are not known for basking or rolling at the surface.
  • Speculative mechanisms. Some enthusiasts have suggested that a few eels might fail to mature and keep growing for unusually long periods. This remains speculation, without evidence that it produces giants.

The more modest version of the theory is easier to accept: that ordinary large eels, briefly glimpsed near the surface in dark water, might be behind some reports of a long, snake-like shape.

The limits of the survey

eDNA is powerful, but it has limits worth keeping in mind:

  • It detects DNA, not animals. It can’t say how many individuals are present or how big they are.
  • DNA breaks down over time, so the survey reflects what was in the loch around the time of sampling, not across its history.
  • Detection depends on reference databases. A truly unknown species could be hard to identify, though its DNA would still be expected to stand out as something unusual.
  • Around 250 samples is a lot, but Loch Ness is a very large body of water.

Even with those caveats, the absence of any reptile DNA, and of the large exotic fish often proposed, is significant. A breeding population of large animals would be expected to leave some trace.

What the survey means for Nessie

The 2018 survey is one of the most rigorous scientific looks at Loch Ness yet. It fits the picture built up by decades of sonar and surface watching: no evidence of a large unknown animal, plenty of ordinary wildlife, and a few possible sources of confusion, eels among them. Combined with the other common explanations, from boat wakes to swimming deer and even circus elephants, it suggests that Nessie is best understood as many different things seen by many different people, not as a single creature waiting to be found.

The complete guide to loch ness monster

The Loch Ness Monster: Sightings, Evidence and What Nessie Could Be
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →