Cryptid Lists

Animals Once Thought to Be Myths: Okapi, Giant Squid, Coelacanth and More

Real animals once thought to be myths or long extinct, from the okapi and giant squid to the coelacanth, plus the legends that real creatures may have inspired.

On this page
  1. Quick answer
  2. Animals science doubted, then confirmed
  3. Back from “extinction”: Lazarus species
  4. Myths with real animals behind them
  5. What these discoveries have in common
  6. What this means for cryptids

Quick answer

Several real animals were long doubted, dismissed or unknown to Western science before being confirmed. The most famous include the okapi (described in 1901), the giant squid (first photographed alive in its natural habitat in 2004), the platypus (thought by some to be a hoax in 1799), the Komodo dragon (documented around 1910), the mountain gorilla (described in 1903) and the coelacanth, a fish known only from fossils until a living one was caught in 1938.

These stories are often quoted by cryptid enthusiasts. They’re worth telling carefully, because they actually fall into three different groups: animals that science didn’t know about, animals presumed extinct that turned out to survive, and myths that real animals may have inspired.

Animals science doubted, then confirmed

Okapi

The okapi is a forest animal of central Africa with a giraffe-like head and zebra-like stripes on its legs. It’s often nicknamed the “African unicorn” or “forest giraffe.” Local people in the Congo rainforest knew it well, but to European naturalists it was just a rumor until the British colonial administrator Sir Harry Johnston obtained pieces of skin and a skull around 1900–1901. It was described scientifically in 1901, and turned out to be the giraffe’s closest living relative. The okapi is the favorite example of cryptozoologists because it went from rumor to confirmed species within a few years.

Giant squid

For centuries, sailors told of enormous many-armed sea monsters. Dead and dying giant squid washed up from time to time, and the genus Architeuthis was named in the 1850s, but no one had seen a healthy one in the deep sea. In 2004, the Japanese researchers Tsunemi Kubodera and Kyoichi Mori photographed a living giant squid at depth near the Ogasawara Islands. Video of a giant squid in its natural habitat followed in 2012. Large specimens are thought to reach roughly 12 meters (about 40 feet) or more including their long feeding tentacles, though many reported sizes are exaggerated.

Platypus

When a platypus skin reached Britain from Australia in the late 1790s, some naturalists suspected a hoax. A duck’s bill sewn onto a mammal seemed far more likely than a real animal, and the zoologist George Shaw, who described it in 1799, reportedly checked for stitches. The platypus turned out to be entirely real: a furred, egg-laying mammal, one of only a handful of living monotremes. Males even carry venomous spurs on their hind legs.

Komodo dragon

Rumors of giant “land crocodiles” on the Indonesian island of Komodo reached European officials in the early twentieth century. Around 1910, the Dutch colonial officer Lieutenant J. K. H. van Steyn van Hensbroek investigated and obtained a specimen, and the animal was formally described in 1912 by Peter Ouwens. At up to about 3 meters long, it’s the largest living lizard.

Mountain gorilla

Gorillas as a group were known to Western science from the 1840s, but the mountain gorilla of the Virunga volcanoes wasn’t described until a German officer, Robert von Beringe, shot two in 1902. It was named in 1903. Before then, reports of giant apes in the mountains were treated with skepticism.

Giant panda

The giant panda was known in China long before Western science described it. The French missionary-naturalist Armand David obtained a skin in 1869, and Western scientists described it soon after. For decades, though, few outsiders saw a living one, and the first live giant panda taken to the West reached the United States in 1936.

Saola

The saola, a forest-dwelling bovine with long, straight horns, was discovered by scientists in 1992 in the Vu Quang area of Vietnam, from horns and skulls kept by local hunters. It’s one of the most striking large-mammal discoveries of the late twentieth century, and it remains so elusive that very few have ever been seen alive by scientists.

Megamouth shark

Not every discovery is ancient history. The megamouth shark, a large filter-feeding shark more than 4 meters long, was unknown to science until 1976, when one became entangled in equipment from a U.S. Navy vessel off Hawaii. Only a few hundred have been recorded since.

Back from “extinction”: Lazarus species

Some animals were known to science, but thought to have died out, until living ones were found. Biologists call these “Lazarus taxa.”

Coelacanth

The coelacanth is the most famous Lazarus species. Coelacanths were known from fossils and thought to have disappeared around the end of the Cretaceous, about 66 million years ago. Then, in December 1938, the museum curator Marjorie Courtenay-Latimer spotted an unusual fish in a trawler’s catch near East London, South Africa. The ichthyologist J. L. B. Smith identified it and named it Latimeria chalumnae in her honor. Living populations were later found around the Comoros, and a second species was identified in Indonesia in the late 1990s.

Chacoan peccary

The Chacoan peccary, a pig-like animal of South America’s dry Chaco region, was first described from fossils and presumed extinct. In the 1970s, scientists confirmed living populations in Paraguay, though local people had known about the animal all along.

Takahē

The takahē, a large, flightless rail from New Zealand, was declared extinct in the late nineteenth century. In 1948, a small population was rediscovered in the remote Murchison Mountains of Fiordland. Intensive conservation has slowly increased its numbers since.

Lord Howe Island stick insect

This large, flightless stick insect, sometimes called a “tree lobster,” was thought to have been wiped out on Lord Howe Island after rats arrived in the early twentieth century. In 2001, researchers found a tiny population on Ball’s Pyramid, a sheer volcanic stack in the ocean nearby, living on a few shrubs.

Myths with real animals behind them

A third group works the other way around. These aren’t real animals once thought mythical, but myths that real animals or fossils may have helped inspire. Some of these links are well supported, and others are plausible theories.

  • Kraken → giant squid. Scandinavian tales of a ship-sized sea monster are widely thought to draw partly on sightings of giant squid and other large cephalopods.
  • Mermaids → manatees and dugongs. On his 1493 voyage, Christopher Columbus reported seeing “mermaids” who were less beautiful than he’d been told. They were almost certainly manatees.
  • Cyclops → dwarf elephant skulls. Fossil skulls of dwarf elephants on Mediterranean islands have a large central nasal opening that could be mistaken for a single eye socket.
  • Unicorn horns → narwhal tusks. Medieval “unicorn horns” sold in Europe were often narwhal tusks.
  • Griffin → Protoceratops? The folklorist Adrienne Mayor has proposed that beaked dinosaur fossils in Central Asia may have influenced griffin legends. The idea is debated.
  • Roc → elephant birds? Madagascar’s extinct elephant birds, which laid enormous eggs, may have fed stories of a giant bird.

If you’re looking for “mythical creatures that actually existed,” these are the closest matches. For forest legends specifically, see our forest mythical creatures list.

What these discoveries have in common

Looking across these cases, a few clear patterns emerge:

  • Local people often knew first. The okapi, saola, Komodo dragon, Chacoan peccary and giant panda were all familiar to people who lived near them long before Western science described them.
  • Physical evidence settled the question. Skins, skulls, bones or a living animal were what turned rumor into science, not eyewitness accounts alone.
  • They live in hard-to-reach places. Dense rainforest, the deep ocean, remote islands and steep mountains.
  • Most are not giants in unexpected places. Even the larger discoveries fit known groups of animals: a giraffe relative, a lizard, a shark, a squid.

What this means for cryptids

These stories are often used to argue that Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster or Mokele-mbembe might be next. It’s true that the world still holds surprises. New species are described every year, including some mammals.

But the cases above also show what a real discovery looks like: within a few years of serious attention, there was a body. The okapi went from rumor to described species quickly once naturalists looked. The world’s most famous cryptids have had decades of searching without producing a single confirmed specimen. For more on how scientists see this argument, see What is cryptozoology?, and for the cryptids themselves, our lists of the top 10 cryptids and rare cryptids.

The closest cryptid parallel to the Lazarus species is the thylacine, a real animal declared extinct but still reported. Whether it could join the coelacanth and the takahē is the question we take up in Is the Tasmanian Tiger Still Alive?

The complete guide to cryptid lists

Rare Cryptids: The Lesser-Known Creatures of Cryptozoology
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →