Appalachian Cryptids

Bigfoot in the Allegheny National Forest

Bigfoot reports from Pennsylvania's Allegheny National Forest: notable sightings, the 2007 Jacobs photos, black bears, likely explanations and where to look.

On this page
  1. The Allegheny National Forest at a Glance
  2. Allegheny Mountains or Allegheny Forest?
  3. Notable Allegheny Bigfoot Reports
  4. Are There Bears in the Allegheny National Forest?
  5. Other Explanations for Allegheny Sightings
  6. Where Are the Most Bigfoot Sightings in Pennsylvania?
  7. What State and Town Are Most Known for Bigfoot?
  8. The Forest County Bigfoot Festival
  9. If You Want to Look for Bigfoot in the Alleghenies

Pennsylvania produces a steady flow of Bigfoot reports, and the Allegheny National Forest in the state’s northwest corner is one of its best-known hotspots. Hunters, anglers, campers and paddlers have described tall, dark, upright figures along its creeks and river corridors, and researchers have collected those accounts for decades.

What the forest has not produced is confirmed physical evidence. The best-known photos have been attributed to a sick bear, and most reports are single, brief eyewitness accounts. Here is what has been reported, what the likely explanations are, and what to know if you want to explore the area yourself.

The Allegheny National Forest at a Glance

The Allegheny National Forest is Pennsylvania’s only national forest. Established in 1923, it covers a little over half a million acres across Elk, Forest, McKean and Warren counties.

  • Terrain: A heavily dissected plateau of steep-sided valleys, flat-topped ridges and hardwood forest, with stands of hemlock along the streams.
  • Water: The Allegheny Reservoir, created by the Kinzua Dam, sits in the north. The Clarion River forms part of the southern edge, and Tionesta Creek and its branches drain much of the interior.
  • Remoteness: It’s one of the least densely populated parts of Pennsylvania, and the surrounding region is marketed as the “Pennsylvania Wilds.”
  • Old growth: Small remnants of old-growth forest survive at places like Hearts Content and the Tionesta area.

The forest isn’t wilderness in the strictest sense. It has a long history of logging and oil and gas extraction and a network of roads and trails. But it does offer large areas of dense cover with few people in them, which is exactly the kind of setting that produces Bigfoot reports.

Allegheny Mountains or Allegheny Forest?

The word “Allegheny” causes some confusion. Geographically, the Allegheny National Forest sits on the Allegheny Plateau. The Allegheny Mountains, including the Allegheny Front and ridges such as Laurel Hill and Chestnut Ridge, run further south and east, through southwestern and central Pennsylvania and into Maryland and West Virginia.

Both areas have Bigfoot traditions. When people talk about “Allegheny Bigfoot,” they may mean either one, and some researchers use the term loosely for the whole western Pennsylvania highlands. This article focuses on the national forest but touches on the wider state picture below.

Notable Allegheny Bigfoot Reports

The 2007 Jacobs Photos

The single best-known piece of Allegheny “evidence” is a pair of trail camera photos taken in September 2007 by a hunter named Rick Jacobs in Elk County, in the area of the national forest. The images show a thin, hunched animal with long limbs and patchy hair, and they spread quickly online as a possible juvenile Bigfoot.

The Pennsylvania Game Commission examined the photos and concluded that the animal was most likely a black bear with a severe case of mange. Sarcoptic mange, caused by a mite, can strip most of a bear’s fur and leave it looking gaunt, long-limbed and strangely humanlike. Mange has been documented in Pennsylvania bears for decades, so the explanation fits local conditions. Some Bigfoot researchers still dispute it, but the Jacobs photos are now more often cited as a lesson in how unusual an ordinary animal can look.

The Clarion River Reports

According to researcher Amy Bue, interviewed by the Pennsylvania Wilds tourism site, several people who did not know each other reported seeing a large upright creature along the same half-mile stretch of the Clarion River in the summer of 2016. Several of them were canoeists and kayakers, the sightings reportedly happened toward evening, and two witnesses said the figure appeared to be striking something on the riverbank with a rock.

Bue has said she only learned of the reports years later, which made any follow-up investigation difficult. The cluster is interesting because of the number of independent witnesses, but it rests on secondhand accounts gathered after the fact.

Tionesta Creek and Campfire Stories

Much of the Allegheny’s Bigfoot lore is the kind told around camp. A common theme is not a clear sighting but sounds: something large and slow wading across Tionesta Creek at night, heavy footsteps in the brush, or the feeling of being watched. Other accounts involve hunters on ATVs or in tree stands who glimpse a tall dark shape that moves away into cover within seconds.

These stories are often told by experienced outdoorspeople, which is part of their appeal. But brief, low-light encounters are exactly the circumstances in which even experienced observers can misjudge size, shape and posture.

Television Attention

Animal Planet’s series Finding Bigfoot visited the Allegheny National Forest region to interview local witnesses, and local press covered the visit in 2013. Programs like this tend to boost interest and report numbers for a few years afterward, which is worth remembering when looking at sighting trends.

Are There Bears in the Allegheny National Forest?

Yes. The Allegheny National Forest is solid black bear country, and north-central and northwestern Pennsylvania hold some of the highest bear densities in the state. Pennsylvania Game Commission estimates have put the statewide population in roughly the 15,000 to 20,000 range in recent years.

That matters for Bigfoot reports because black bears:

  • regularly stand and even walk short distances on their hind legs, especially to look around or reach food
  • can appear 6 feet tall or more when standing
  • vary in color and, with mange, can look nearly hairless or oddly proportioned
  • leave tracks that, when the front and hind prints overlap, can look like a single large, humanlike footprint

Black bears are generally shy and attacks are rare, but they are large wild animals. Follow Pennsylvania Game Commission and Forest Service guidance on storing food, keeping a clean camp and never approaching or feeding bears.

Other Explanations for Allegheny Sightings

Bears are the leading candidate, but they aren’t the only one:

  • Elk. Pennsylvania’s wild elk herd is centered in Elk and Cameron counties, just southeast of the forest. A bull elk’s bugle is a high, eerie whistle-scream that surprises people who haven’t heard one.
  • Owls, foxes and coyotes. Barred owls, red foxes and coyotes can all produce screams, howls and calls that sound human or unnatural at night.
  • People. Hunters, anglers and hikers in dark clothing, seen briefly at a distance, are a common source of mistaken sightings.
  • Hoaxes. Costumes, fake footprints and staged photos are well documented in Bigfoot research generally.
  • Expectation. In a region known for Bigfoot, ambiguous shapes and sounds are more likely to be interpreted that way.

None of this proves every witness was mistaken. It does mean that a single sighting, without physical evidence, can’t settle the question.

Where Are the Most Bigfoot Sightings in Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania regularly ranks among the states with the most reports in the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization (BFRO) database. Within the state, reports are spread widely, but two areas come up again and again:

  • Southwestern Pennsylvania, especially Westmoreland and Fayette counties and the Chestnut Ridge and Laurel Highlands area. Researcher Stan Gordon documented a notable wave of reports there in the early 1970s, some involving alleged UFO activity as well.
  • The north-central and northwestern forests, including the Allegheny National Forest and the wider Pennsylvania Wilds.

Report counts reflect where people are and who files reports as much as where any animal might be, so they should be read with caution.

What State and Town Are Most Known for Bigfoot?

Washington State usually leads the BFRO’s report counts, and the Pacific Northwest as a whole is the heartland of the Bigfoot legend. California has the strongest historic claim: the name “Bigfoot” took off after reports of giant tracks in Humboldt County in 1958, and the 1967 Patterson–Gimlin film was shot at Bluff Creek in the same region.

The town most closely associated with Bigfoot is probably Willow Creek, California, which calls itself the “Bigfoot Capital of the World” and has a museum collection devoted to the creature. In Pennsylvania, Marienville on the edge of the Allegheny National Forest has adopted Bigfoot as a local theme through its festival.

The Forest County Bigfoot Festival

The Forest County Bigfoot Festival is held in Marienville and has become one of the region’s better-known cryptid events. It typically features guest speakers, vendors, family activities and a 5K. Dates and programs change, so check the festival’s official site before planning a trip.

If You Want to Look for Bigfoot in the Alleghenies

If you want to explore the forest with Bigfoot in mind, a few practical points:

  • Follow forest rules. Check Forest Service rules on camping, campfires and motor vehicles, and be aware of hunting seasons. Wear blaze orange when hunters are out.
  • Document carefully. Note the date, time, exact location, weather and light conditions. Photograph tracks with a scale reference, and record sounds with the time noted.
  • Consider the ordinary first. Bears, elk and other wildlife will account for most of what you see and hear, and learning their tracks and calls makes any genuinely odd observation more credible.
  • Report it. Organizations such as the BFRO and regional groups collect sighting reports. Be aware that their databases are not peer-reviewed.
  • Respect private land. Much of the land in and around the forest is privately owned. Get permission before going onto it.

For more of the region’s creatures, from Mothman to the Wampus Cat, see our list of Appalachian cryptids, or read about other mountain cryptids like the Yeti and the Yowie.

The complete guide to appalachian cryptids

List of Appalachian Cryptids
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →