American Lake Monsters

What monster is in Bear Lake?

The monster in Bear Lake is the Bear Lake Monster, a serpent-like creature from 1868 newspaper stories its author later admitted were invented. Here's the full story.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What the Bear Lake Monster supposedly looks like
  3. How the legend began
  4. Sightings after the hoax
  5. Bear Lake itself
  6. What lives in Bear Lake
  7. Is the Bear Lake Monster real?
  8. The monster today
  9. FAQ

The short answer

The monster in Bear Lake is the Bear Lake Monster, a legendary serpent-like creature said to live in Bear Lake on the Utah–Idaho border. It became famous in 1868 through a series of newspaper stories by Joseph C. Rich, a local settler. Rich is widely reported to have later admitted that he made them up. Despite that, people continued to report sightings for decades, and the creature is now a much-loved local mascot.

There is no evidence that an unknown large animal lives in Bear Lake. The real lake is remarkable in its own right, with striking turquoise water and several fish species found nowhere else in the world. The Bear Lake Monster is one of several North American lake monsters often compared with Scotland’s Nessie.

What the Bear Lake Monster supposedly looks like

Descriptions from the 19th-century stories and later reports vary a great deal, but common features include:

  • A long, serpentine body, with lengths from around 30 feet to more than 90 feet in the more dramatic tales
  • Short legs or flippers, which set it apart from many other lake monsters
  • A large head variously likened to an alligator, a horse, a cow or a walrus, sometimes with tusks or “ears”
  • Great speed, with early stories claiming it swam faster than a train
  • Loud roaring or hissing noises
  • Occasional trips onto land, in some versions

The wildly varying details are typical of a story that spread through retelling and newspaper embellishment.

How the legend began

Earlier Native American stories

Some sources say the Shoshone and other Native peoples of the region had traditions about a dangerous water creature in the lake, sometimes said to have carried people off. These traditions are hard to document from the available sources. It is also unclear how far later writers shaped them to fit the monster story. They are best treated as part of the background rather than as a firm origin.

Joseph C. Rich and the 1868 newspaper reports

Bear Lake Valley was settled by Latter-day Saint (Mormon) pioneers in the 1860s, and Joseph C. Rich was among the prominent settlers. In 1868, he wrote a series of reports for the Deseret News, the Salt Lake City newspaper. They described local people encountering a huge animal in the lake: a long, brown, serpent-like creature with a head like a walrus, seen swimming at great speed.

The stories caused a sensation across Utah Territory. Other newspapers picked them up, debates broke out over whether they were true, and more “sightings” quickly followed. According to a frequently repeated story, Brigham Young, then president of the church, took enough interest that he sent a long, heavy rope to help settlers try to catch the creature. Details of this anecdote vary, and it should be read as part of the legend rather than a verified fact.

The admission

Rich is widely reported to have eventually acknowledged that the creature was his invention, often described as a way to draw attention and settlers to the remote valley. Retellings disagree over exactly when and how he made the admission. Most modern historical accounts, including those from Utah institutions, treat the 1868 reports as a hoax or tall tale.

The Bear Lake Monster fits a well-known 19th-century pattern. Local papers often published colorful tall tales, and readers were not always sure where the joke ended. A similar story played out in Iowa with the Skunk River Monster.

Sightings after the hoax

A confessed hoax usually ends a legend, but the Bear Lake Monster kept going. Reports continued into the 20th century, with sightings commonly cited from the early 1900s, the 1930s and the 1940s, and occasional claims into the 2000s. Some may have been jokes, and some honest misidentifications of logs, waves, waterfowl or large fish. Others probably reflect how a well-known story primes people to interpret anything odd on the water as “the monster”.

In recent years, viral images and videos of the creature have circulated online. Many are obviously edited or digitally generated, and none has provided credible evidence.

Bear Lake itself

Bear Lake straddles the border between northern Utah and southeastern Idaho. It is roughly 20 miles long and up to about 8 miles wide, with a maximum depth of around 200 feet. Its most striking feature is its color. The water often looks a brilliant turquoise blue, which has earned it the nickname “Caribbean of the Rockies”. The color comes from fine particles of calcium carbonate (limestone) suspended in the water, which scatter sunlight.

Towns around the lake include Garden City and Laketown in Utah and Fish Haven, St. Charles and Paris in Idaho. The area is a popular summer destination for boating, swimming and fishing.

What lives in Bear Lake

Bear Lake is ancient and has been isolated for a long time, so it is home to several fish found nowhere else on Earth:

  • Bonneville cisco, a small fish that gathers in large numbers near shore to spawn in winter, drawing anglers with dip nets
  • Bear Lake whitefish
  • Bonneville whitefish
  • Bear Lake sculpin, a small bottom-dwelling fish

The lake also supports Bonneville cutthroat trout, which can grow fairly large, and lake trout. None of these is anywhere near monster size. Still, a large trout rolling at the surface on a calm evening can catch the eye.

Is the Bear Lake Monster real?

On the evidence, no. The legend’s famous origin is widely acknowledged as a hoax. Later sightings are scattered and inconsistent, and nothing physical has ever been found. The lake’s food web is well studied and dominated by relatively small fish, which makes a population of giant predators very unlikely.

That does not make the legend worthless. It is a revealing piece of frontier history, showing how stories spread in the 1860s, how communities built identity in a new settlement, and how a joke can outlive its teller.

The monster today

Today the Bear Lake Monster is a friendly symbol of the region. Visitors can find:

  • Monster-themed boat rides on the lake, aboard a boat styled like a green sea serpent
  • Souvenirs, signs and murals featuring the creature in towns around the lake
  • Local celebrations, such as Garden City’s Raspberry Days festival, where the monster sometimes makes an appearance
  • Historical collections, such as material held by Utah State University’s library

The creature’s shift from a frightening tale to a cheerful mascot mirrors what happened with Champ of Lake Champlain and Bessie of Lake Erie.

FAQ

Where is Bear Lake?

Bear Lake sits on the border of northern Utah and southeastern Idaho, in the Rocky Mountains, northeast of Logan, Utah.

Who invented the Bear Lake Monster?

Joseph C. Rich, a Bear Lake Valley settler, popularized the creature in 1868 newspaper stories and is widely reported to have later admitted they were invented.

Why is Bear Lake so blue?

Fine particles of calcium carbonate suspended in the water scatter sunlight, giving the lake its distinctive turquoise color.

Are there any dangerous animals in Bear Lake?

No large dangerous aquatic animals are known from Bear Lake. Its fish are mostly trout, whitefish, cisco and sculpin. As at any lake, the real hazards are things like cold water, wind and boating accidents.

The complete guide to american lake monsters

American Nessies: North America's Lake Monsters
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →